Paramedic Workforce Disparities Marked by Geographical Positioning Comparison of Rural and Urban Regions
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
Introduction: Effective service delivery and the wellbeing of the paramedic workforce is reliant on confounding factors and is effectuated by geographical positioning. It is important to be aware that there may be several disparities between the rural and urban workforce due to differences in circumstances. However, there is limited literature available examining these. The objective of this review was to investigate where and how these disparities exist to make recommendations in achieving equity in the paramedic workforce and thus achieve patient-centred care universally across rural and urban populations.
Methods: The JBI approach was used to perform a scoping review to assess the availability of literature. Key words including paramedic*, EMT, urban OR metro*, rural OR remote and disparit* were inserted into the search engines MEDLINE, CINAHL Plus and Scopus. Titles and abstracts of the 282 results were screened by two authors and inclusion and exclusion criteria applied. The full text of the remaining 77 results were screened to inform the results of the review.
Results: The search identified 282 potentially relevant articles, of which 33 informed the results of the review. The included studies identified emerging themes relevant to the objective including: (1) the skills, training availability and confidence of the workforce (2) resourcing of ambulances inclusive of both workload and case load; (3) timings of each group regarding response, scene, and transport; and (4) the health status of paramedics in each subset location.
Conclusion: This review identified several disparities between rural and urban paramedic locations. However, it does not allow us to understand the extent at which these influence paramedics health and wellbeing and their ability to provide optimal patient-centred care which is equitable across locations. Further research is recommended to establish the extent to which these disparities are impacting the lives of paramedics and provision of emergency healthcare.
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Publishing in IJOP allows authors to keep their copyright while giving IJOP unrestricted copyright permissions. Articles published in IJOP use Creative Common Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY-ND 4.0) licensing. This license requires that re-users give credit to the creator. It allows re-users to copy and distribute the material in any medium or format in unadapted form only, even for commercial purposes. Additional terms apply and can be accessed here.
Publishing in IJOP also allows authors to have contracts for non-exclusive distribution of the Journal's published version of the article, such as posting to an institutional repository or publication in a book, on the condition that the original publication in the original layout format in IJOP is retained and acknowledged.
We permit and encourage authors to post the articles they published in IJOP on their affiliated websites. This helps share the information, encourages citation in other works, and promotes scholarly discourse in the spirit of open access.
References
Adeyemi, O. J., Paul, R., & Arif, A. (2022). An assessment of the rural‐urban differences in the crash response time and county‐level crash fatalities in the United States. The Journal of rural health, 38(4), 999-1010. doi:10.1111/jrh.12627
Aftyka, A., Rybojad, B., & Rudnicka-Drozak, E. (2014). Are there any differences in medical emergency team interventions between rural and urban areas? A single-centre cohort study. Australian Journal of Rural Health, 22(5), 223-228.
Alanazy, A., Fraser, J., & Wark, S. (2021). Provision of emergency medical services in rural and urban saudi arabia: An overview of personnel experiences. Asia Pacific Journal of Health Management, 16(2).
Alanazy Ahmed Ramdan, M., Fraser, J., & Wark, S. (2021). Organisational factors affecting emergency medical services' performance in rural and urban areas of Saudi Arabia. BMC health services research, 21(1), 562-562.
Alanazy Ahmed Ramdan, M., Wark, S., Fraser, J., & Nagle, A. (2019). Factors Impacting Patient Outcomes Associated with Use of Emergency Medical Services Operating in Urban Versus Rural Areas: A Systematic Review. International journal of environmental research and public health, 16(10).
Alanazy, A. R. M., Fraser, J., & Wark, S. (2022). Emergency medical services in rural and urban Saudi Arabia: A qualitative study of Red Crescent emergency personnel' perceptions of workforce and patient factors impacting effective delivery. Health and Social Care in the Community, 30(6), e4556-e4563.
Alanazy, A. R. M., Wark, S., Fraser, J., & Nagle, A. (2020). Utilization of prehospital emergency medical services in Saudi Arabia: An urban versus rural comparison. Journal of Emergency Medicine, Trauma and Acute Care, 2020(2).
Anderson, T. J., Saman, D. M., Lipsky, M. S., & Lutfiyya, M. N. (2015). A cross-sectional study on health differences between rural and non-rural US counties using the County Health Rankings. BMC health services research, 15, 1-8.
Ashburn Nicklaus, P., Snavely Anna, C., Angi Ryan, M., Scheidler James, F., Crowe Remle, P., McGinnis Henderson, D., . . . Stopyra Jason, P. (2022). Prehospital time for patients with acute cardiac complaints: A rural health disparity. American Journal of Emergency Medicine, 52, 64-68.
Ashburn, N. P., Hendley, N. W., Angi, R. M., Starnes, A. B., Nelson, R. D., McGinnis, H. D., . . . Stopyra, J. P. (2020). Prehospital trauma scene and transport times for pediatric and adult patients. Western Journal of Emergency Medicine, 21(2), 455-462.
Bennett, C. L., Sullivan, A. F., Ginde, A. A., Rogers, J., Espinola, J. A., Clay, C. E., & Camargo Jr, C. A. (2020). National study of the emergency physician workforce, 2020. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 76(6), 695-708.
Bush, M., Glickman Lawrence, T., Fernandez Antonio, R., Garvey, J. L., & Glickman Seth, W. (2013). Variation in the use of 12-lead electrocardiography for patients with chest pain by emergency medical services in North Carolina. Journal of the American Heart Association, 2(4), e000289-e000289.
Cash, R. E., Crowe, R. P., Bower, J. K., Foraker, R. E., & Panchal, A. R. (2019). Differences in Cardiovascular Health Metrics in Emergency Medical Technicians Compared to Paramedics: A Cross-Sectional Study of Emergency Medical Services Professionals. Prehospital and disaster medicine, 34(3), 288-296. doi:10.1017/S1049023X19004254
Clark David, E., Winchell Robert, J., & Betensky Rebecca, A. (2013). Estimating the effect of emergency care on early survival after traffic crashes. Accident; analysis and prevention, 60, 141-147.
Coleman, N., Barry, T., Tobin, H., Conroy, N., & Bury, G. (2019). Paediatric airway management and concerns: a survey of advanced paramedics in Ireland. Irish journal of medical science, 188(2), 683-688.
Connolly, M. S., Goldstein Pcp, J. P., Currie, M., Carter, A. J. E., Doucette, S. P., Giddens, K., . . . Sapp, J. L. (2022). Urban-Rural Differences in Cardiac Arrest Outcomes: A Retrospective Population-Based Cohort Study. CJC Open, 4(4), 383-389.
Cosgrave, C., Hussain, R., & Maple, M. (2015). Retention challenge facing A ustralia's rural community mental health services: Service managers' perspectives. Australian Journal of Rural Health, 23(5), 272-276.
Courtney, J., Francis, A., & Paxton, S. (2013). Caring for the Country: Fatigue, Sleep and Mental Health in Australian Rural Paramedic Shiftworkers. Journal of Community Health, 38(1), 178-186. doi:10.1007/s10900-012-9599-z
Cui Eric, R., Fernandez Antonio, R., Zegre-Hemsey Jessica, K., Grover Joseph, M., Honvoh, G., Brice Jane, H., . . . Patel Mehul, D. (2021). Disparities in Emergency Medical Services Time Intervals for Patients with Suspected Acute Coronary Syndrome: Findings from the North Carolina Prehospital Medical Information System. Journal of the American Heart Association, 10(15), 1-12.
Deeb, A.-P., Phelos Heather, M., Peitzman Andrew, B., Billiar Timothy, R., Sperry Jason, L., & Brown Joshua, B. (2020). Disparities in rural versus urban field triage: Risk and mitigating factors for undertriage. Journal of Trauma & Acute Care Surgery, 89(1), 246-253.
Emond, K., Bish, M., Savic, M., Lubman Dan, I., McCann, T., Smith, K., & Mnatzaganian, G. (2021). Characteristics of Confidence and Preparedness in Paramedics in Metropolitan, Regional, and Rural Australia to Manage Mental-Health-Related Presentations: A Cross-Sectional Study. International journal of environmental research and public health, 18(4).
Hegenberg, K., Trentzsch, H., Gross, S., & Pruckner, S. (2019). Use of pre-hospital emergency medical services in urban and rural municipalities over a 10 year period: an observational study based on routinely collected dispatch data. Scandinavian journal of trauma, resuscitation and emergency medicine, 27(1), 35.
Hodell, E., Hughes Shana, D., Corry, M., Kivlehan, S., Resler, B., Sheon, N., & Govindarajan, P. (2016). Paramedic Perspectives on Barriers to Prehospital Acute Stroke Recognition. Prehospital emergency care : official journal of the National Association of EMS Physicians and the National Association of State EMS Directors, 20(3), 415-424.
Hsu, Y.-C., Wu, W.-T., Huang, J.-B., Lee, K.-H., & Cheng, F.-J. (2021). Association between prehospital prognostic factors and out-of-hospital cardiac arrest: Effect of rural-urban disparities. American Journal of Emergency Medicine, 46, 456-461.
Irvine, R., Doan, T., Bosley, E., Colbeck, M., & Bowles, K. A. (2022). Pediatric Out-of-Hospital Cardiac Arrests: An Epidemiological Study. Prehospital emergency care.
Jegasothy, E., McGuire, R., Nairn, J., Fawcett, R., & Scalley, B. (2017). Extreme climatic conditions and health service utilisation across rural and metropolitan New South Wales. International journal of biometeorology, 61(8), 1359-1370.
Johnson, C. C., Vega, L., Kohalmi, A. L., Roth, J. C., Howell, B. R., & Van Hasselt, V. B. (2020). Enhancing Mental Health Treatment for the Firefighter Population: Understanding Fire Culture, Treatment Barriers, Practice Implications, and Research Directions. Professional psychology, research and practice, 51(3), 304-311. doi:10.1037/pro0000266
Kett, P. M., Bekemeier, B., Patterson, D. G., & Schaffer, K. (2023). Competencies, Training Needs, and Turnover Among Rural Compared With Urban Local Public Health Practitioners: 2021 Public Health Workforce Interests and Needs Survey. American journal of public health (1971), 113(6), 689-699. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2023.307273
Liu, C. (2022). Exploration of the police response time to motor-vehicle crashes in Pennsylvania, USA. Journal of safety research, 80, 243-253. doi:10.1016/j.jsr.2021.12.006
Lu, Y., & Davidson, A. (2017). Fatal motor vehicle crashes in Texas: needs for and access to emergency medical services. Annals of GIS, 23(1), 41-54.
Mahajan, K., & Velaga, N. R. (2022). Effects of partial sleep deprivation: A comparative assessment of young non-professional and professional taxi drivers. Transportation research. Part F, Traffic psychology and behaviour, 85, 209-220. doi:10.1016/j.trf.2022.01.008
Malatzky, C., & Bourke, L. (2018). Different perspectives on the key challenges facing rural health: The challenges of power and knowledge. The Australian journal of rural health, 26(6), 436-440. doi:10.1111/ajr.12436
Martin Lorelle, K., Lewis Virginia, J., Clark, D., Murphy Maria, C., Edvardsson, D., Stub, D., & Farouque, O. (2020). Frontline barriers to effective paramedic and emergency nursing STEMI management: clinician perspectives. Australasian emergency care, 23(2), 126-136.
Masuda, J., Kishi, M., Kumagai, N., Yamazaki, T., Sakata, K., Higuma, T., . . . Ito, M. (2018). Rural-Urban Disparity in Emergency Care for Acute Myocardial Infarction in Japan. Circulation journal : official journal of the Japanese Circulation Society, 82(6), 1666-1674.
McGrail, M. R., Humphreys, J. S., Joyce, C. M., Scott, A., & Kalb, G. (2012). How do rural GPs' workloads and work activities differ with community size compared with metropolitan practice? Australian journal of primary health, 18(3), 228-233. doi:10.1071/PY11063
Meadley, B., Caldwell, J., Perraton, L., Bonham, M., Wolkow, A. P., Smith, K., . . . Bowles, K.-A. (2020). The health and well-being of paramedics - a professional priority. Occupational medicine (Oxford), 70(3), 149-151. doi:10.1093/occmed/kqaa039
Miller, K. E. M., James, H. J., Holmes, G. M., & Van Houtven, C. H. (2020). The effect of rural hospital closures on emergency medical service response and transport times. Health services research, 55(2), 288-300. doi:10.1111/1475-6773.13254
Mitchell, R. J., & Lower, T. (2018). Rural–urban variation in injury‐related hospitalisation, health outcomes and treatment cost in New South Wales. Australian Journal of Rural Health, 26(3), 165-172.
Moafa Hassan, N., van Kuijk Sander Martijn, J., Alqahtani Dhafer, M., Moukhyer Mohammed, E., & Haak Harm, R. (2020). Disparities between Rural and Urban Areas of the Central Region of Saudi Arabia in the Utilization and Time-Centeredness of Emergency Medical Services. International journal of environmental research and public health, 17(21).
Newgard Craig, D., Rongwei, F., Bulger, E., Hedges Jerris, R., Mann, N. C., Wright Dagan, A., . . . Fu, R. (2017). Evaluation of Rural vs Urban Trauma Patients Served by 9-1-1 Emergency Medical Services. JAMA Surgery, 152(1), 11-18.
Nordberg, P., Jonsson, M., Forsberg, S., Ringh, M., Fredman, D., Riva, G., . . . Hollenberg, J. (2015). The survival benefit of dual dispatch of EMS and fire-fighters in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest may differ depending on population density--a prospective cohort study. Resuscitation, 90, 143-149.
Pyper, Z., & Paterson, J. L. (2016). Fatigue and mental health in Australian rural and regional ambulance personnel. EMA - Emergency Medicine Australasia, 28(1), 62-66.
Ro, Y. S., Shin, S. D., Song, K. J., Lee, E. J., Kim, J. Y., Ahn, K. O., . . . Hwang, S. S. (2013). A trend in epidemiology and outcomes of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest by urbanization level: A nationwide observational study from 2006 to 2010 in South Korea. Resuscitation, 84(5), 547-557.
Roberts, R., Wong, A., Jenkins, S., Neher, A., Sutton, C., O’Meara, P., . . . Dwivedi, A. (2021). Mental health and well‐being impacts of COVID‐19 on rural paramedics, police, community nurses and child protection workers. The Australian journal of rural health, 29(5), 753-767. doi:10.1111/ajr.12804
Rosvall, P.-Å. (2020). Counselling to stay or to leave?-Comparing career counselling of young people in rural and urban areas. Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education, 50(7), 1014-1032.
Sariyer, G., Ataman, M. G., SofuoÄlu, T., & SofuoÄlu, Z. (2017). Does ambulance utilization differ between urban and rural regions: a study of 112 services in a populated city, Izmir. Journal of Public Health (Germany), 25(4), 379-385.
Smith, T., English, T., Whitman, M., Lewis, D., & Gregg, A. (2022). The Impact of Rural Hospital Closures on Emergency Medical Services Transport Times. Online journal of rural nursing and health care, 22(1), 26-41. doi:10.14574/ojrnhc.v22i1.690
Sofianopoulos, S., Williams, B., & Archer, F. (2012). Paramedics and the effects of shift work on sleep: a literature review. Emergency Medicine Journal : EMJ, 29(2), 152-155. doi:10.1136/emj.2010.094342
Spencer-Goodsir, H., Anderson, J., & Sutton, C. (2022). The nature of paramedic practice in rural and remote locations: A scoping review.
Steinhaeuser, J., Joos, S., Szecsenyi, J., & Miksch, A. (2011). A comparison of the workload of rural and urban primary care physicians in Germany: analysis of a questionnaire survey. BMC family practice, 12(1), 112-112. doi:10.1186/1471-2296-12-112
Stopyra, J. P., Crowe, R. P., Snavely, A. C., Supples, M. W., Page, N., Smith, Z., . . . Mahler, S. A. (2022). Prehospital Time Disparities for Rural Patients with Suspected STEMI. Prehospital emergency care.
Taylor, Y. L. H. (2020). Shift Workers, Fatigued Driving and the Impact on Road Safety : an Investigation Involving Police Service Employees. ProQuest Dissertations Publishing,
Tham, R., Pascoe, A., Willis, K., Kay, M., & Smallwood, N. (2022). Differences in psychosocial distress among rural and metropolitan health care workers during the COVID‐19 pandemic. The Australian journal of rural health, 30(5), 683-696. doi:10.1111/ajr.12873
Wan Jusoh, W. N., Tharima, A. F., Ghani, W., Mohamad Lukman, N. H., Visvasathan, S., Shamsudin, M. H., . . . Mohd Nur, N. (2023). Initial Assessment of Fire Response Time between Different Categories of Fire Stations in Malaysia. Fire (Basel, Switzerland), 6(1), 6. doi:10.3390/fire6010006
Welfare, A. I. o. H. a. (2018). Australia's Health 2018. Retrieved from Canberra:
Wong Ho, T., Lin, T.-K., & Lin, J.-J. (2019). Identifying rural-urban differences in the predictors of emergency ambulance service demand and misuse. Journal of the Formosan Medical Association, 118(1), 324-331.
Wubben, B. M., Denning, G. M., & Jennissen, C. A. (2019). The Effect of All-Terrain Vehicle Crash Location on Emergency Medical Services Time Intervals. Safety (Basel), 5(4), 73. doi:10.3390/safety5040073
Yeap, E., Morrison, J., Apodaca, A., Egan, G., & Jansen, J. (2014). Trauma care in Scotland: effect of rurality on ambulance travel times and level of destination healthcare facility. European Journal of Trauma & Emergency Surgery, 40(3), 295-302