A Systematic Review of the Evidence for Using Simulation to Replace Clinical Experience for Paramedic Students Simulation to Replace Clinical Experience
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
Background In health professions education there is a shortage of clinical training opportunities and an increasing demand for workers, creating a need for alternative methods to clinical placements. One alternative method to replace clinical experience is simulation-based education. Currently, the efficacy of simulation as a clinical replacement in paramedicine is unknown. To understand the current state of evidence for substituting clinical experience with simulation in paramedic education, provide implications for SBE implementation, and direct further research in this area a systematic review, following the PRISMA checklist guide, was conducted.
Methods Five databases were searched. Primary source studies of all designs investigating replacing clinical experience in paramedicine were included, with eight articles assessed for eligibility screening. Three studies were selected for final inclusion, quality assessment and critical appraisal.
Results Inter-rater reliability was good for the quality assessment and quality appraisal ratings were moderate to strong, though the articles were of low levels of evidence. None of the studies directly addressed whether simulation-based education can be used as a clinical replacement, though both learners and program directors found value in simulation and felt a combination of simulation and clinical time was best. Communication skills and high-acuity low-frequency situations were identified as most appropriate for simulation substitution.
Discussion The findings of the systematic review indicate a willingness to engage in simulation to replace some clinical experience and certain skill areas that could be suitable for simulation, but no practical recommendations can be made due to the low level of study design based on the levels of evidence and lack of evidence for direct clinical substitution. Simulation as a replacement for clinical experience has support in other health professions, but further research is needed in paramedicine to investigate its efficacy and to inform future educational practice.
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Publishing in IJOP allows authors to keep their copyright while giving IJOP unrestricted copyright permissions. Articles published in IJOP use Creative Common Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY-ND 4.0) licensing. This license requires that re-users give credit to the creator. It allows re-users to copy and distribute the material in any medium or format in unadapted form only, even for commercial purposes. Additional terms apply and can be accessed here.
Publishing in IJOP also allows authors to have contracts for non-exclusive distribution of the Journal's published version of the article, such as posting to an institutional repository or publication in a book, on the condition that the original publication in the original layout format in IJOP is retained and acknowledged.
We permit and encourage authors to post the articles they published in IJOP on their affiliated websites. This helps share the information, encourages citation in other works, and promotes scholarly discourse in the spirit of open access.
References
Al Asmri, M., Haque, M. S., & Parle, J. (2023). A Modified Medical Education Research Study Quality Instrument (MMERSQI) developed by Delphi consensus. BMC Medical Education, 23(1), 63. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-023-04033-6
Anton, N., Calhoun, A. C., & Stefanidis, D. (2022). Current Research Priorities in Healthcare Simulation: Results of a Delphi Survey. Simulation in Healthcare: The Journal of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare, 17(1), e1–e7. https://doi.org/10.1097/SIH.0000000000000564
Aromataris, E., Lockwood, C., Porritt, K., Pilla, B., & Jordan, Z. (Eds.). (2024). JBI Manual for Evidence Synthesis. JBI. https://doi.org/10.46658/JBIMES-24-01
Bienstock, J., Heuer, A., & Zhang, Y. (2022). Simulation-Based Training and Its Use Amongst Practicing Paramedics and Emergency Medical Technicians: An Evidence-Based Systematic Review. International Journal of Paramedicine, 1, 12–28. https://doi.org/10.56068/VWHV8080
Bishen, S., & Jacquet, P. (2023). Global Health and Healthcare Strategic Outlook: Shaping the Future of Health and Healthcare. World Economic Forum.
Bogossian, F. E., Cant, R. P., Ballard, E. L., Cooper, S. J., Levett‐Jones, T. L., McKenna, L. G., Ng, L. C., & Seaton, P. C. (2019). Locating “gold standard” evidence for simulation as a substitute for clinical practice in prelicensure health professional education: A systematic review. Journal of Clinical Nursing, 28(21–22), 3759–3775. https://doi.org/10.1111/jocn.14965
Breymier, T. L., Rutherford-Hemming, T., Horsley, T. L., Atz, T., Smith, L. G., Badowski, D., & Connor, K. (2015). Substitution of Clinical Experience With Simulation in Prelicensure Nursing Programs: A National Survey in the United States. Clinical Simulation In Nursing, 11(11), 472–478. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecns.2015.09.004
Cash, R. E., Rivard, M. K., Chrzan, K., Mercer, C. B., Camargo Jr., C. A., & Panchal, A. R. (2021). Comparison of Volunteer and Paid EMS Professionals in the United States. Prehospital Emergency Care, 25(2), 205–212. https://doi.org/10.1080/10903127.2020.1752867
CoAEMSP Interpretations of the CAAHEP 2023 standards and guidelines. (2024). Commission on Accreditation of Educational Programs for the Emergency Medical Services Professionals (CoAEMSP). https://coaemsp.org/resource-library
Credland, N., Rodgers, A., Hurwood, M., & McKenzie, J. (2020). Student paramedic perceptions of a non-ambulance practice learning experience. Nurse Education Today, 88, 104374. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2020.104374
Curry-Lourenco, K., Sherraden Bradley, C., White, P., Loomis, A., Childress, R. M., & Waxman, K. (2022). Where Are We Now? A Follow-up Survey on Regulation of Simulation Use in United States Prelicensure Nursing Programs. Clinical Simulation in Nursing, 72, 9–14. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecns.2022.06.007
Diamond, A., & Bilton, N. (2021). The Current State on the Use of Simulation in Paramedic Education. Australasian Journal of Paramedicine, 18, 1–5. https://doi.org/10.33151/ajp.18.903
Downing, D., Chang, T. P., Robertson, J. M., Anderson, M., Diaz, D. A., Spain, A. E., & the Terminology and Concepts Working Group. (2020). Healthcare simulation dictionary (L. Lioce & L. Lopreiato, Eds.; Second Edition). Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. DOI: https://doi.org/10.23970/simulationv2.
Drummond, D., Sinclair, D., & Gratton, J. (2022). Troubles in Canada’s Health Workforce: The Why, the Where, and the Way Out of Shortages. C.D. Howe Institute.
Fleiss, J. L., Levin, B., & Paik, M. C. (2003). Statistical Methods for Rates and Proportions (1st ed.). Wiley. https://doi.org/10.1002/0471445428
Gamer, M., Lemon, J., Fellows, I., & Singh, P. (2019). irr: Various Coefficients of Interrater Reliability and Agreement (0.84.1) [R].
Giblett, N., Rathore, R., & Carruthers, D. (2017). Simulating the Surgical Patient Pathway for Undergraduates. Journal of Surgical Education, 74(2), 271–276. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsurg.2016.10.003
Hayden, J. K., Smiley, R. A., Alexander, M., Kardong-Edgren, S., & Jeffries, P. R. (2014). The NCSBN National Simulation Study: A Longitudinal, Randomized, Controlled Study Replacing Clinical Hours with Simulation in Prelicensure Nursing Education. Journal of Nursing Regulation, 5(2), Supplement.
Hill, A. E., Ward, E., Heard, R., McAllister, S., McCabe, P., Penman, A., Caird, E., Aldridge, D., Baldac, S., Cardell, E., Davenport, R., Davidson, B., Hewat, S., Howells, S., Purcell, A., & Walters, J. (2021). Simulation can replace part of speech-language pathology placement time: A randomised controlled trial. International Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 23(1), 92–102. https://doi.org/10.1080/17549507.2020.1722238
JBI Levels of Evidence. (2014). https://jbi.global/sites/default/files/2020-07/Supporting_Doc_JBI_Levels_of_Evidence.pdf
Jimenez, Y. A., Gray, F., Di Michele, L., Said, S., Reed, W., & Kench, P. (2023). Can simulation-based education or other education interventions replace clinical placement in medical radiation sciences? A narrative review. Radiography, 29(2), 421–427. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.radi.2023.02.003
Lasserson, T. J., Thomas, J., & Higgins, J. P. T. (n.d.). Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions. Chapter 1: Starting a review. https://training.cochrane.org/handbook/current/chapter-01
Lockwood, C., Munn, Z., & Porritt, K. (2015). Qualitative research synthesis: Methodological guidance for systematic reviewers utilizing meta-aggregation. International Journal of Evidence-Based Healthcare, 13(3), 179–187. https://doi.org/10.1097/XEB.0000000000000062
McGregor, R., Pollard, K., Davidson, R., & Moss, C. (2020). Providing a sustainable sonographer workforce in Australia: Clinical training solutions. Sonography, 7(4), 141–147. https://doi.org/10.1002/sono.12239
McKenna, K. D., Carhart, E., Bercher, D., Spain, A., Todaro, J., & Freel, J. (2015). Simulation Use in Paramedic Education Research (SUPER): A Descriptive Study. Prehospital Emergency Care, 19(3), 432–440. https://doi.org/10.3109/10903127.2014.995845
McLeod, C., Jokwiro, Y., Gong, Y., Irvine, S., & Edvardsson, K. (2021). Undergraduate nursing student and preceptors’ experiences of clinical placement through an innovative clinical school supervision model. Nurse Education in Practice, 51, 102986. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nepr.2021.102986
Newton, J., Carpenter, T., & Zwicker, J. (2024). Exploring paramedic perspectives on emergency medical service (EMS) delivery in Alberta: A qualitative study. BMC Emergency Medicine, 24(1), 66. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12873-024-00986-z
Nyoni, C. N., Dyk, L. H.-V., & Botma, Y. (2021). Clinical placement models for undergraduate health professions students: A scoping review. BMC Medical Education, 21(1), 598. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-021-03023-w
Page, D., Brazelton, T., Kokx, G., Jennings, P. A., & Williams, B. (2021). Paramedic student encounters with patients during clinical placements: A multi-institutional cohort study. Journal of the American College of Emergency Physicians Open, 2(2), e12391. https://doi.org/10.1002/emp2.12391
Page, M. J., McKenzie, J. E., Bossuyt, P. M., Boutron, I., Hoffmann, T. C., Mulrow, C. D., Shamseer, L., Tetzlaff, J. M., Akl, E. A., Brennan, S. E., Chou, R., Glanville, J., Grimshaw, J. M., Hróbjartsson, A., Lalu, M. M., Li, T., Loder, E. W., Mayo-Wilson, E., McDonald, S., … Moher, D. (2021). The PRISMA 2020 statement: An updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. BMJ (Clinical Research Ed.), 372, n71. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.n71
Pearce, R., Topping, A., & Willis, C. (2022). Enhancing healthcare students’ clinical placement experiences. Nursing Standard, 37(5), 29–34. https://doi.org/10.7748/ns.2022.e11887
Roberts, E., Kaak, V., & Rolley, J. (2019). Simulation to Replace Clinical Hours in Nursing: A Meta-narrative Review. Clinical Simulation in Nursing, 37, 5–13. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecns.2019.07.003
Smith, G. (2017). The Challenges of Paramedic Education in the New Millennium: Chasing the Evolution of Paramedic Practice. Australasian Journal of Paramedicine, 14, 1–3. https://doi.org/10.33151/ajp.14.4.613
Squires, K., Heaney, S., MacDonald-Wicks, L., Johnston, C., & Brown, L. (2022). Mapping Simulated-Based Learning Experiences Incorporated Into Professional Placements in Allied Health Programs: A Scoping Review. Simulation in Healthcare: The Journal of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare, 17(6), 403–415. https://doi.org/10.1097/SIH.0000000000000627
Supplement to the National Occupational Competency Profile, 2014 Appendix A High Fidelity Simulation. (2014). Paramedic Association of Canada. https://paramedic.ca/documents/NOCP%20Appendix%20A%202014.pdf
Takats, S., Stillman, D., Cheslack-Postava, F., Bagdonas, M., Jellinek, A., Najdek, T., Petrov, D., Rentka, M., & Venčkauskas, A. (n.d.). Zotero (6.0.37) [Computer software]. Corporation for Digital Scholarship. https://www.zotero.org/
Vandenbroucke, F. (2024). Working together to advance resilient health systems across the OECD. The Lancet, 403(10425), 415–416. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(24)00129-6
Watson, K., Wright, A., Morris, N., McMeeken, J., Rivett, D., Blackstock, F., Jones, A., Haines, T., O’Connor, V., Watson, G., Peterson, R., & Jull, G. (2012). Can simulation replace part of clinical time? Two parallel randomised controlled trials. Medical Education, 46(7), 657–667. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2923.2012.04295.x
Watts, P. I., Rossler, K., Bowler, F., Miller, C., Charnetski, M., Decker, S., Molloy, M. A., Persico, L., McMahon, E., McDermott, D., & Hallmark, B. (2021). Onward and Upward: Introducing the Healthcare Simulation Standards of Best PracticeTM. Clinical Simulation In Nursing, 58, 1–4. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecns.2021.08.006
Wheeler, B., & Dippenaar, E. (2020). The use of simulation as a teaching modality for paramedic education: A scoping review. British Paramedic Journal, 5(3), 31–43. https://doi.org/10.29045/14784726.2020.12.5.3.31
Whitten-Chung, K. (2023). Directors’ Perceptions of Supplementing Clinical Requirements with Simulation-Based Education in Paramedic Education [Dissertations/Theses - Doctoral Dissertations]. https://libezproxy.nait.ca/login?url=https://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=eric&AN=ED635997&site=ehost-live&scope=site
Williams, B., Brown, T., & Archer, F. (2009). Can DVD simulations provide an effective alternative for paramedic clinical placement education? Emergency Medicine Journal: EMJ, 26(5), 377–381. https://doi.org/10.1136/emj.2008.060723